FBC Melgar 1–1 Comerciantes Unidos: Match Result & Summary
Match analysis, backed by data: match events, available team statistics, recent form, team news and lineup context.
Recorded forecast & result
Match winner
✗ Missed- Forecast
- FBC Melgar · 71%
- Result
- Draw
The score went against the chances
Comerciantes Unidos had the better chances (xG 0.7–1.3), but it ended 1–1.
Expected goals (xG) add up how good each side's chances were: a penalty is about 0.8, a shot from distance about 0.03.
How the chances moved
🟥2
4' · FBC Melgar · red card · Horacio Orzan
9' · FBC Melgar · goal · Johnny Vidales
⚽
86' · Comerciantes Unidos · goal · Jose Antonio·Parodi
FBC MelgarDrawComerciantes Unidos
Estimated result after 90 minutes, including added time. Based on the pre-match forecast and match events; the published forecast stays unchanged.
Match events
FBC MelgarComerciantes Unidos
- 4'Horacio Orzan
- 9'Johnny VidalesCristian Bordacahar
- 20'Matías Cordova
- 28'Miguel Rondelli
- 29'Jhon Sánchez Piero Guzmán
- 45'Alexis Cossio Daniel Lino
- 45'Thiago Alessandro Salinas Melgar Yimy Gamero
- 45+1'Lautaro Guzmán
- 45+1'Matías Eric Sen
- Half-time
- 49'Juan Rodríguez
- 55'Thiago Alessandro Salinas Melgar Goal cancelled
- 64'Franco Zanelatto Johnny Vidales
- 66'Maximiliano Pérez Josuee Herrera
- 67'Agustín Rodríguez
- 70'Jean Olivares Agustín Rodríguez
- 70'Matias Zegarra Lautaro Guzmán
- 77'Marcos Portillo Nicolas Quagliata
- 86'Jose Antonio·ParodiMatías Eric Sen
- 90+1'Flavio Alcedo
- Full time
Team stats
FBC MelgarComerciantes Unidos
- 34%Possession66%
- 0.65Expected goals (xG)1.27
- 12Shots20
- 4Shots on target8
- 6Corners4
- 7Saves3
- 11Fouls17
- 0Offsides1
- 1Yellow cards5
- 1Red cards0
Full AI analysis →Team news, injuries and lineups read by our AI scouts, updated when the official lineups are out. How it works
KickoffHour pre-match forecast
Pre-match win probabilities
FBC Melgar to win: 71%, about 3 in 4
Goals3+ in the match57%Market 59%
Forecast results
Match winner
✗ Missed- Forecast
- FBC Melgar · 71%
- Result
- Draw
Match analysis in brief
FBC Melgar host Comerciantes Unidos in Arequipa with Melgar chasing a Clausura play-off place and Comerciantes fighting relegation. Melgar are unbeaten in four but missing captain and top scorer Bernardo Cuesta, whose availability sources contradict. Comerciantes come off a 3-1 win over Cienciano under new coach Claudio Biaggio.
Key match facts
- FBC Melgar: 2 out — Bernardo Cuesta and Jefferson Cáceres
- Rest: FBC Melgar 6 days, Comerciantes Unidos 4
By the numbers
FBC Melgar23% Bernardo Cuesta is not startingHis share of their attacking actions. Sides without two key attackers create about 9% less.
FBC Melgar15 goals Bernardo Cuesta is not starting todayTheir top league scorer this season.
FBC Melgar6 games unbeaten in the league: 4 wins, 2 drawsLast league defeat: 1 Sep 2026.
Comerciantes Unidos2016 last win over FBC Melgar1 Apr 2016. Since then: 7 draws, 3 defeats in 10 meetings.
Comerciantes Unidos1,370 km trip to this gameFrom 600 km, visitors win 2-3 in 100 fewer games than their rating suggests.tilts towards FBC Melgar
Comerciantes Unidos0 of 5 wins on their last 5 visitsAt FBC Melgar, since 2016. Not one in our records, back to 2016.
More match facts
- FBC Melgar: 4 wins in their last 6 league games. Comerciantes Unidos: 1 win in their last 6.
- Comerciantes Unidos have won 0 of their last 5 visits to FBC Melgar (no wins, 2 draws, 3 defeats).
"Tilts towards": this factor, tested across thousands of games, nudges the match that way - not who is favourite overall.
Match context
- Travel for Comerciantes Unidos
- 1,370 km
- Rest days
- FBC Melgar 6Comerciantes Unidos 4
- Matches in the last 14 days: FBC Melgar 2 · Comerciantes Unidos 2
- Weather at kick-off
- 15°C · wind 7 km/h
- Dry
- Referee
- Rudy Mendez
- Expected yellow cards: about 4.3 (both teams' rates and the referee's).
- Coaches
- Miguel Rondelli
- FBC Melgar
- Claudio Biaggio
- Comerciantes Unidos
- Goals in this league
- Liga 1 Peru average: 2.81 per match
Players in form
FBC Melgar: last 5 games
- Bernardo Cuesta4 goals
- N. Quagliata2 goals · 2 assists
- C. Bordacahar2 goals
Comerciantes Unidos: last 5 games
- Rodrigo Gary Vilca Betetta2 goals · 1 assist
- J. Herrera1 goal · 1 assist
- J. Olivares1 goal · 1 assist
Goals and assists in each team's latest matches, all competitions. Who is available for this match: see the Lineups tab.
Corners and cards
| Per game | League | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Corners won | 5.1 | 3.8 | 4.4 |
| Corners conceded | 4.4 | 4.8 | 4.4 |
| Corners, both teams | 9.5 | 8.5 | 8.9 |
| Yellow cards | 1.9 | 2.3 | 2.2 |
| Yellow cards, both teams | 3.8 | 4.7 | 4.4 |
| Fouls | 9.8 | 11.9 | 11.7 |
Liga 1 Peru matches this season before kick-off, 30 games each. Past averages, not a forecast.
Team news & sources
What the sources report on match day, with links.
- Melgar sit 5th with 25 points from 13 games and have won their last two league matches.[4]
- Melgar are unbeaten in four games, including a 2-1 win at UTC Cajamarca on 23 October.[2]
- Comerciantes Unidos are 13th with 13 points and beat Cienciano 3-1 on 25 October in their most recent match.[2]
- Comerciantes have lost nine away games this season, winning only two.[4]
- Melgar need points to stay in the top places of the Clausura, with only six points separating first from eighth and four rounds remaining.[1][5]
- Comerciantes need points to secure their Liga 1 survival and are aiming for a second straight win under new coach Claudio Biaggio.[1][5]
- Melgar face leaders Sport Huancayo away on 2 November, three days after this match.[3][5]
- Comerciantes' top scorer Matías Sen has ten goals this season.[4]
Sources
- libero.pe – Melgar vs Comerciantes Unidos EN VIVO por Torneo ...
- rpp.pe – Melgar vs Comerciantes Unidos en vivo a qué hora, canal ...
- bolavip.com – Alineaciones de Melgar y Comerciantes Unidos por la Liga 1
- foxsports.com – FBC Melgar vs. Comerciantes Unidos: Oct 30, 2026
- diariocorreo.pe – Liga 1: FBC Melgar no puede volver a fallar | DEPORTES
Goals and other probabilities
Win or draw (double chance)
- FBC Melgar win or draw
- 89%
- Either team wins (no draw)
- 82%
- Comerciantes Unidos win or draw
- 28%
Goals in the match (over/under)
- 2+ goals
- 79%
- 3+ goals
- 57%
- 4+ goals
- 34%
Both teams score (BTTS)
- Yes
- 46%
- No
- 54%
We expect about 2.2 goals from FBC Melgar and 0.7 from Comerciantes Unidos. (expected goals)
Most likely scores (exact score)
Most likely score: 2–0 (13%). Even the likeliest exact score happens only about 1 time in 8. Next: 1–0 (12%), 3–0 (10%), 2–1 (9%), 1–1 (8%).
Forecast updates
- First read · 3 updates Our call: FBC Melgar Data forecast: prices, form, ratings. No news yet.
- Match-day analysis Our call: FBC Melgar · no change vs the stage before Our AI scouts read the team news, injuries and local sources.
- Final, with lineups Counted Our call: FBC Melgar · -1 pts vs the stage before Re-read when the official team sheets are out; the scouts can still change their mind.
The last version before kick-off is the one in our track record. All versions
AI match analysis: what our scouts say
1 of 3 think a draw is underrated.
The Coach
tactics and lineupsMelgar's depth covers Cuesta's absence at altitude, but Comerciantes' full squad keeps a draw live
Melgar line up without captain and top scorer Cuesta and Cáceres, but Minda is cleared to start and only Tandazo remains doubtful. Comerciantes name an unchanged, fully available XI with top scorer Sen leading the line. Both set up 4-2-3-1 in Arequipa's altitude.
The Dressing Room
mood and pressureMelgar's strong form and home advantage should see them secure the win.
FBC Melgar has been in strong recent form, securing four games unbeaten, while Comerciantes Unidos has been irregular in their last five matches. Melgar is chasing a top-four finish in the Clausura, adding significant pressure to this fixture.
The Sceptic
where the market may be wrongMelgar's strong form and home advantage give them the edge, but a draw remains a significant possibility.
Comerciantes Unidos is irregular in their last five matches. The match is played at high altitude in Arequipa, and the head-to-head record shows 7 draws in 11 meetings.
AI analysts are automated roles, not people. Their leans are analysis, not recommendations. Who reads the game best
The Verdict
Our numbers stay close to the bookmakers' because the reported absences and Melgar's situation are already in the prices, and The Sceptic's five-point shift to the draw was not followed since the head-to-head sample is small and old. The Coach's view that Melgar's depth covers the absences was the one largely adopted, while The Dressing Room's motivation argument was set aside as something the prices already include.
How we got to these numbers
| Home | Draw | Away | 3+ goals | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bookmakers | 72% | 17% | 11% | 59% |
| AI analysts | 63% | 22% | 15% | 61% |
| Our forecast | 71% | 18% | 11% | 57% |
Our forecast combines available statistical and market information with a constrained assessment of relevant team news. Methodology
Prediction history
| # | Published | Home | Draw | Away | Reason | Record |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 78% | 14% | 8% | Stats preview | #3024 | |
| 2 | 75% | 16% | 9% | Prices moved | #3170 | |
| 3 | 72% | 17% | 11% | Prices moved | #3230 | |
| 4 | 72% | 17% | 11% | Full analysis | #3273 | |
| 5 | 71% | 18% | 11% | Official lineups | #3289 |
Frozen at kick-off. Version 5 is the one that counts in our track record. Every version is in the public ledger (how to check).
Starting lineups Confirmed
FBC Melgar
4-2-3-1Coach M. Rondelli
Substitutes (9)
90J. AlcántarD63
FBC Melgar · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 23
- Height
- 190 cm
- Minutes
- 1159
- Starts
- 11
- Goals
- 2
- Assists
- 0
20G. GarcíaM—
FBC Melgar · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 21
- Height
- 161 cm
- Minutes
- 155
- Starts
- 0
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
36P. NunezM—
FBC Melgar · this season · all competitions
- Age
- —
- Height
- —
- Minutes
- 8
- Starts
- 0
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
26M. PortilloM71
FBC Melgar · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 26
- Height
- —
- Minutes
- 253
- Starts
- 2
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
- 40R. YabikuF—
77F. ZanelattoF59
FBC Melgar · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 26
- Height
- 175 cm
- Minutes
- 417
- Starts
- 4
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 1
45Matias ZegarraD63
FBC Melgar · this season · all competitions
- Age
- —
- Height
- —
- Minutes
- 1788
- Starts
- 20
- Goals
- 3
- Assists
- 5
12C. CácedaG59
FBC Melgar · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 35
- Height
- 184 cm
- Minutes
- 720
- Starts
- 8
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
80J. D´ArrigoM59
FBC Melgar · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 27
- Height
- 168 cm
- Minutes
- 369
- Starts
- 1
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
FBC Melgar · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 25
- Height
- 188 cm
- Minutes
- 2340
- Starts
- 26
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
FBC Melgar · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 23
- Height
- 186 cm
- Minutes
- 2742
- Starts
- 32
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 4
FBC Melgar · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 27
- Height
- 182 cm
- Minutes
- 1133
- Starts
- 12
- Goals
- 1
- Assists
- 0
FBC Melgar · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 32
- Height
- 179 cm
- Minutes
- 1440
- Starts
- 16
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
FBC Melgar · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 26
- Height
- 171 cm
- Minutes
- 1684
- Starts
- 21
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 3
FBC Melgar · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 38
- Height
- 177 cm
- Minutes
- 632
- Starts
- 7
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 1
FBC Melgar · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 27
- Height
- 176 cm
- Minutes
- 1301
- Starts
- 15
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
FBC Melgar · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 35
- Height
- 179 cm
- Minutes
- 1763
- Starts
- 21
- Goals
- 7
- Assists
- 2
FBC Melgar · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 27
- Height
- 170 cm
- Minutes
- 2182
- Starts
- 26
- Goals
- 7
- Assists
- 12
FBC Melgar · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 26
- Height
- 173 cm
- Minutes
- 1090
- Starts
- 13
- Goals
- 2
- Assists
- 2
FBC Melgar · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 34
- Height
- 180 cm
- Minutes
- 2482
- Starts
- 29
- Goals
- 14
- Assists
- 1
- Regular starters
- 8 of 11
- Changes vs last XI in this competition
- 3
- Minutes per player · last 14 days
- 127
Comerciantes Unidos
4-2-3-1Coach C. Biaggio
Goalkeeper
- 17Matías Cordova
Defenders
40F. Alcedo
Comerciantes Unidos · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 23
- Height
- 182 cm
- Minutes
- 2073
- Starts
- 25
- Goals
- 2
- Assists
- 0
30P. Guzmán
Comerciantes Unidos · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 26
- Height
- 191 cm
- Minutes
- 1478
- Starts
- 17
- Goals
- 1
- Assists
- 0
6J. Rodriguez
Comerciantes Unidos · this season · all competitions
- Age
- —
- Height
- —
- Minutes
- 2756
- Starts
- 31
- Goals
- 4
- Assists
- 1
19D. Lino
Comerciantes Unidos · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 24
- Height
- 184 cm
- Minutes
- 790
- Starts
- 10
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
Midfielders
18A. Rodríguez
Comerciantes Unidos · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 26
- Height
- 175 cm
- Minutes
- 1922
- Starts
- 24
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
54Y. Gamero
Comerciantes Unidos · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 24
- Height
- 174 cm
- Minutes
- 291
- Starts
- 5
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 1
20J. Parodi
Comerciantes Unidos · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 29
- Height
- 179 cm
- Minutes
- 1368
- Starts
- 15
- Goals
- 2
- Assists
- 0
25Rodrigo Gary Vilca Betetta
Comerciantes Unidos · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 27
- Height
- 175 cm
- Minutes
- 2612
- Starts
- 31
- Goals
- 7
- Assists
- 8
11J. Herrera
Comerciantes Unidos · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 27
- Height
- —
- Minutes
- 1126
- Starts
- 15
- Goals
- 5
- Assists
- 3
Forward
9M. Sen
Comerciantes Unidos · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 35
- Height
- 184 cm
- Minutes
- 2482
- Starts
- 27
- Goals
- 11
- Assists
- 3
Substitutes (9)
10M. CarpioM60
Comerciantes Unidos · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 24
- Height
- 169 cm
- Minutes
- 503
- Starts
- 6
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 2
99José Pablo Alejandro Charún ValdezG—
Comerciantes Unidos · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 29
- Height
- 185 cm
- Minutes
- 90
- Starts
- 0
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
15A. CossioD62
Comerciantes Unidos · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 31
- Height
- 186 cm
- Minutes
- 2430
- Starts
- 26
- Goals
- 1
- Assists
- 2
50J. OlivaresF59
Comerciantes Unidos · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 24
- Height
- —
- Minutes
- 1104
- Starts
- 13
- Goals
- 3
- Assists
- 3
28O. PintoM57
Comerciantes Unidos · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 24
- Height
- 177 cm
- Minutes
- 230
- Starts
- 0
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
13M. PérezF62
Comerciantes Unidos · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 31
- Height
- 185 cm
- Minutes
- 870
- Starts
- 9
- Goals
- 4
- Assists
- 0
14Thiago SalinasM61
Comerciantes Unidos · this season · all competitions
- Age
- —
- Height
- —
- Minutes
- 661
- Starts
- 2
- Goals
- 1
- Assists
- 2
8W. AyovíF67
Comerciantes Unidos · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 29
- Height
- 168 cm
- Minutes
- 510
- Starts
- 3
- Goals
- 2
- Assists
- 2
32J. SánchezF63
Comerciantes Unidos · this season · all competitions
- Age
- 27
- Height
- 175 cm
- Minutes
- 720
- Starts
- 8
- Goals
- 2
- Assists
- 0
Recent formations
Starting shapes in the available completed matches before this fixture, across all competitions. A formation label does not establish a playing style or an advantage.
FBC Melgar
10 recorded team sheets · 9 Aug 2026 – 23 Oct 2026
Confirmed for this match: 4-2-3-1
- 4-2-3-1
- 8 of 10
- 4-4-2
- 1 of 10
- 3-4-2-1
- 1 of 10
Latest recorded shape before this match: 4-2-3-1
Comerciantes Unidos
10 recorded team sheets · 7 Aug 2026 – 25 Oct 2026
Confirmed for this match: 4-2-3-1
- 4-2-3-1
- 5 of 10
- 4-4-2
- 4 of 10
- 4-4-1-1
- 1 of 10
Latest recorded shape before this match: 4-2-3-1
Confirmed lineups are from this match’s official team sheets · updated UK time (GMT). Rating: our 40–99 scale, adjusted for league strength. Tap a player for season statistics.
Team news: injuries and suspensions
Team comparison
League matches this season before kick-off, 30 games each. Highlighted: the better figure.
Recent form
Before kick-off · all competitions · oldest to newest, left to right.
FBC Melgar: last 6 games
- Wins
- 4
- Draws
- 2
- Losses
- 0
- Goals scored
- 13
- Goals against
- 6
WWDDWW
All 6 matches
Comerciantes Unidos: last 6 games
- Wins
- 1
- Draws
- 2
- Losses
- 3
- Goals scored
- 9
- Goals against
- 11
DLLDLW
All 6 matches
Liga 1 Peru table: now
The table as it is today, this match included. Positions in the header and in our preview are from kick-off.
| # | Team | Pld | GD | Pts | League form |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 | Sporting Cristal | 16 | +17 | 32 | DWWLW |
| 3 | Universitario | 16 | +11 | 32 | DDWWW |
| 4 | Deportivo Garcilaso | 17 | +12 | 30 | DDWLW |
| 5 | FBC Melgar | 16 | +9 | 29 | WLDWW |
| 6 | Alianza Lima | 16 | +8 | 29 | DWLWW |
| 7 | Alianza Atlético | 16 | -1 | 28 | LWWLL |
| 8 | Sport Boys | 17 | +6 | 27 | DDDWW |
| 9 | Juan Pablo II College | 17 | +7 | 26 | DLLWL |
| 10 | Cusco FC | 17 | +2 | 25 | DLLWW |
| 11 | Atlético Grau | 17 | -4 | 21 | LWLLD |
| 12 | Comerciantes Unidos | 17 | -1 | 17 | DDDDW |
| 13 | Cienciano | 16 | -4 | 17 | LLWLW |
| 14 | UCV Moquegua | 17 | -13 | 15 | WDDLL |
| 15 | FC Cajamarca | 16 | -14 | 14 | WLLLL |
Head-to-head
Last 6 meetings: FBC Melgar won 2, Comerciantes Unidos 0, 4 draws; 2.0 goals per game.
- Published
- UK time (GMT)
- Updated
- UK time (GMT)
This analysis was generated automatically by an AI model from public sources. How it works →
18+ · Predictions are probabilities, not certainties. If you bet, bet only what you can afford to lose. Responsible gambling

